Every Agency Showed Me Screenshots of Results: How to Tell Evidence From Decoration, and What to Ask For Instead

The short answer: your position is right: do not hand your budget to anyone who has not shown you real results. But a screenshot from an ad account is one slice of a result with no context. The evidence that protects you is a client you can call, a written definition of an opportunity, the cost per qualified opportunity rather than per click, and what that client’s sales team said afterwards. An agency that will not show other clients’ dashboards without permission will treat your data the same way.

In 40 seconds

  • An RFP asked every agency for case studies, ad-platform screenshots of results and one contactable reference. One agency said it shares these only with client permission and after verification.
  • A screenshot proves some number in some period; nothing about budget, sector, lead quality or what followed the click.
  • Four questions turn a case into evidence: whose campaign; what counted as an opportunity; cost per qualified opportunity; what sales said afterwards.
  • Ask instead for a reference call, an anonymised sample report, a tracking plan, and a 90-day pilot with decision gates.

“I will not hand my budget to anyone until I see real results”

An RFP reached us from a company that sells to other businesses. The evidence clause was explicit: case studies for two or three clients, actual results for at least one backed by ad-platform screenshots, and one reference client the buyer could call. One agency replied that it supplies all of this only after its clients’ permission and after verifying the numbers, knowing other bidders would simply attach screenshots. From the buyer’s chair, the natural reaction is suspicion.

The clause is right in substance. An annual engagement can run past EGP 1 million or SAR 200,000 in fees and ad spend, and a three-to-nine-month sales cycle means you learn the truth half a year after you start paying. The mistake is defining proof as “a picture from the ad account”. Not everyone who attaches one is misleading you, but the screenshot alone cannot separate the honest from the decorated.

Why a screenshot proves less than it seems

A screenshot showing “cost per result $3” or “2,000 leads this month” can be cropped to its best month in two minutes, and leaves unanswered everything that determines its value to you:

  • No budget or country. $1,000 or $50,000, Egypt or Saudi Arabia? An industrial keyword behaves nothing like a retail one.
  • Possibly the wrong sector. Many screenshots in B2B proposals come from consumer campaigns, where thousands of cheap inquiries are normal; a manufacturer closes ten buyers a year.
  • Unknown lead quality. A platform “lead” is anyone who filled a form: a student, a job seeker, a competitor, which is why so many companies get many leads but almost no opportunities.
  • Nothing after the click. Did anyone reply? Did inquiries become quotations? Did a deal close? The platform does not know.

In B2B services and industrial products the cost per qualified opportunity typically sits in the hundreds of dollars or the local equivalent and moves a long way with country, keyword and deal size; hear it with its conditions, not cropped from a screen.

Four questions that turn a case study into evidence

A case study is not the problem; reading it as an advertisement is. Four questions:

  • Whose campaign is this, and may I call them? A case with no name is a story; a client who takes a ten-minute call is evidence. Consent at shortlist stage is acceptable.
  • What counted as a lead, and what as an opportunity? Without a written definition the number means nothing: a quotation request, an accepted meeting, or any form?
  • What was the cost per qualified opportunity, not per click? The only figure you can set against your budget and deal value. An agency that says it varies by country and sector is being honest, not evasive.
  • What did the client’s sales team say happened next? How many reached a quotation, how many closed, after how many months. Only an agency working inside the client’s CRM can answer.

Answer all four and the screenshot no longer matters; answer none and it does not fill the gap.

Why an agency that protects its clients’ dashboards is protecting you too

Once you sign, the agency has access to your ad account, your inquiries, your customers’ names in the CRM and your sales figures. Next year you will be the case study in a proposal to another company, possibly a competitor. An agency that attached a former client’s dashboard without asking will do the same with yours. “We share after permission and verification” means there is a procedure, numbers are reviewed, and your data will be handled the same way. An agency that declines the screenshot but offers a reference call and a sample report is protecting its clients; one that offers nothing has nothing to protect.

What to ask for instead of screenshots

Change the evidence clause in your RFP from “screenshots” to verifiable requests:

What the agency showsWhat it actually provesWhat to ask for instead
An ad-platform screenshot with clicks and form countsSome number in some period; no budget, sector or quality attachedA reference call with a client in a comparable B2B cycle, with consent
An unnamed case study with a large growth percentageThere is a story; starting point and definition of the result unknownA real sample monthly report, numbers anonymised: qualified opportunities, cost and source
A testimonial from “a marketing manager” with no companySomeone wrote a kind sentenceThe tracking plan it would build for you: what is measured, where, how it reaches the CRM
A promise of a monthly number of leadsNothing; volume can be bought by widening the audienceA 90-day pilot with written decision gates that stop or extend it
Logos of well-known clients on the last pageSome engagement happened, possibly a business card designThe scope with each logo, the year, whether it still runs

The sample report is the strongest request: it shows whether the agency measures reach and likes or qualified opportunities with cost and source, as the B2B marketing agency page describes. The tracking plan makes those numbers believable: a form recorded with its source, a WhatsApp click tied to its campaign, a conversion sent from the server; see the server-side tracking service page, setup from $500 one-time.

How to weigh “no screenshots” against “lots of screenshots” when scoring

Give “provided screenshots” no weight in your scoring grid. Weight what can be verified: a reference you actually called, a definition of a qualified opportunity, a sample report, a tracking plan, decision gates in the pilot. No screenshots plus those five outranks twenty screenshots and none of them. To build the RFP on that logic, see how to write a B2B marketing RFP that gets you comparable proposals. Deduct immediately for:

  • Guaranteed lead numbers: hit by widening the audience; you pay for the qualification.
  • Results from another country or sector presented as proof for you.
  • No mention of CRM or qualification anywhere in the proposal.
  • Numbers with no period and no budget: 60% from what, on what spend, over which months?

A serious B2B pilot starts around $2,000 a month or the local equivalent, roughly EGP 100,000 or SAR 7,500 including ad spend, because one qualified opportunity in your sector can be worth hundreds of thousands or millions in local currency. Our integrated B2B marketing system starts from $800 a month, about EGP 40,000.

Six questions before you accept any evidence in a marketing proposal

  • Can I call at least one client from your case studies, after their consent?
  • What is your written definition of a lead and a qualified opportunity in this case?
  • What was the cost per qualified opportunity, on what budget, where, over which period?
  • Can you send a sample monthly report with the numbers anonymised?
  • What tracking plan would you build, and how do inquiries reach our CRM with their source?
  • How will you treat our data if another prospect asks for a case study about us?

When we’re the right fit — and when we’re not

VadeCom is the right fit if you sell to businesses in Egypt or the Gulf with large deals and a three-to-nine-month cycle and want evidence you can verify: references after their owners’ consent, an anonymised sample report, a written tracking plan before signature, and a pilot with decision gates instead of a closed annual contract. We are not the right fit if your first criterion is the number of screenshots, you want a guaranteed lead count, or you sell to consumers on a cycle measured in days. Send your RFP through the form on our site.

Related reading

FAQ

Should I ask for screenshots of client results?

You can, but give it no weight. A screenshot proves a number in a period with no budget or sector attached; ask instead for a contactable reference, an opportunity definition, cost per qualified opportunity and a sample report.

Is refusing to show client results without permission a bad sign?

No, provided it offers an alternative: a reference call after consent, an anonymised sample report, a tracking plan. A refusal with nothing in its place is the bad sign.

Which number should I compare proposals on?

Cost per qualified opportunity: a quotation request or an accepted meeting. In B2B it usually sits in the hundreds of dollars or the local equivalent and varies with country, keyword and deal size.

What should a sample monthly report show?

A real report for another client, names and numbers anonymised: qualified opportunities, their cost, their source and how many reached sales. If it is reach and likes, that is what you will receive.

How much does a pilot that can judge an agency cost?

Around $2,000 a month or the local equivalent including ad spend, over 90 days with decision gates. Our integrated system starts from $800 a month, about EGP 40,000; server-side tracking setup from $500 one-time.

share post on :

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

suggest for you

Marketing

Every Agency Showed Me Screenshots of Results: How to Tell Evidence From Decoration, and What to Ask For Instead

An RFP asked every agency for ad-platform screenshots of client results. From the buyer's side: why a screenshot proves little, the four questions that turn ...
Marketing

Door-to-Door Freight: Where Cash Goes Missing Between the Courier and the Treasury, and the System That Closes the Gap

A freight owner says his couriers are honest and the money always arrives. The fourth Solutions We Built case: the first version of a system ...
Marketing

I Asked for Service-by-Service Pricing So I Can Compare and Choose: What Can Really Be Unbundled, and What Is the Base Nothing Works Without?

A buyer comparing agencies asked for a price per service. The request is right; the risk is unbundling. Which lines are modular, which are the ...
Marketing

A Recruitment Agency Wants Saudi and Gulf Employers With a Real Hiring Need: How to Identify Them, Reach the Decision-Maker and Book Meetings

A licensed recruitment agency in Egypt has candidates ready but does not know which Gulf employer needs them now. The answer is an outbound, account-based ...
Marketing

A Signage and Illuminated-Letters Manufacturer Wants Contracts in Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the UAE: Identity First, Then Where Do the RFQs Come From?

A signage manufacturer that builds identities for others has none of its own and wants contracts in Egypt, Saudi Arabia and the UAE. The answer: ...